Contact Us

Contact Shelbyville Insurance

Shelbyville Insurance is prepared to provide you with a no cost, no obligation review and comparison of your insurance.

210 North Morgan
Shelbyville, Illinois 62565
Phone: 217-774-2155 or 800-580-2155
FAX: 217-774-2158

Monday – Friday 8:00a.m. to 4:30p.m.

After Hours by Appointment

Our Staff

  • Randy Biehler, Principal
  • Danny Reynolds, Principal
  • Darren Reynolds, Principal
  • Daniel Reynolds, Principal
  • Gary Arthur, Producer
  • Derek Hayden, Producer
  • Keith Probst, Producer
  • Rachel Wallace, Office Manager, Commercial CSR
  • Vicki Burrus, Personal CSR
  • Kristine Gambrill, Personal CSR
  • Cathy Biddlecombe, Life/Health CSR